caseline.

Jennifer Pan

Markham, Ontario · 2010–2026

BP

Bich-Ha Pan

Victim

HP

Hann Pan

Surviving victim

Bich-Ha Pan died on the night of November 8, 2010. Hann Pan was seriously hurt and survived.

Where it stands now

Checked Oct 7, 2026

Jennifer Pan pleaded guilty in March 2026 to manslaughter in her mother's death and has a life sentence. Her conviction for the attempted murder of her father still stands, and she can apply for parole.

Watched What Jennifer Did?

People look Jennifer Pan up because of the court case. Her brother, a family member who gave a statement to the court, wrote that he had seen the family's tragedy turned into entertainment for strangers.

2 of 35
Netflix documentary
What happened
Investigation
Courts
Media
Sources disagree AI draft Date is a best placement Key moment Quiet years folded, not to scale
What happenedNov 8, 2010 · 6:12 to 10:05 p.m.

Call

Evening calls

Minute. The dissenting reasons in the Supreme Court give 6:12 p.m. and 10:05 p.m. from the call records, and a call at 9:11 p.m.

Earliest source on this page: The Canadian Press, via CBC News, Aug 21, 2014, 3 years, 9 months later.

Drafted by AI research. An editor hasn’t reviewed this moment yet.

Markham Civic Centre, a brick municipal building with a rotunda, behind a pond with a fountain.
Markham Civic Centre, the city hall. A public building, not the home or the street. Raysonho @ Open Grid Scheduler / Grid Engine, CC0 1.0

Through the evening, Jennifer Pan's phone records show calls with Lenford Crawford, Daniel Wong, and David Mylvaganam, and many texts with Wong. Two calls from Mylvaganam's phone came shortly before the home invasion. Mylvaganam said at trial that Eric Carty made those calls on his phone.

What the sources say

  1. Her call records indicate calls with Lenford Crawford, Daniel Wong, and David Mylvaganam between 6:12 p.m. and 10:05 p.m., along with many texts with Mr. Wong during that same time frame. She spoke on the phone for nearly one minute with Mr. Wong at 9:11 p.m.

    Confirmed(in the dissenting reasons' account of the trial evidence)Supreme Court of Canada, R. v. Pan, 2025 SCC 12, para. 197 (Karakatsanis J., dissenting in part)Decision ↗

  2. Shortly before the shootings, Mylvaganam's phone called Pan twice.

    Confirmed(as the Court of Appeal summarized the prosecution's case)Court of Appeal for Ontario, R. v. Pan, 2023 ONCA 362, May 19, 2023, para. 12Decision ↗

  3. Mylvaganam disputed that he made the two calls to Pan that evening. He said Eric Carty made them using his phone, as Carty had done on other occasions.

    Sources disagree(as his position at trial)Court of Appeal for Ontario, R. v. Pan, 2023 ONCA 362, May 19, 2023, para. 15Decision ↗

  4. Jennifer Pan testified that she received three calls that evening asking whether she had the cancellation money ready, that she said she did not, and that she did not expect anyone to come to her home that evening.

    Confirmed(as her testimony, summarized by the Court of Appeal)Court of Appeal for Ontario, R. v. Pan, 2023 ONCA 362, May 19, 2023, para. 14Decision ↗

  5. Pan testified that as the night went on, she got calls from people she didn't know asking whether she had the money. She said she told them she didn't have the full amount and wouldn't have it that day.

    Reported(as her testimony)The Canadian Press, via CBC News, August 21, 2014Story ↗

  6. Toronto Life reports that Mylvaganam called Pan at 9:35 p.m. and they spoke for nearly two minutes, and that he called again at 10:05 p.m. and they spoke for three and a half minutes.

    Reported(in Toronto Life's account of the case)Karen K. Ho, Toronto Life, July 22, 2015Feature ↗

    Note: Toronto Life says Mylvaganam made the calls. At trial he said Eric Carty used his phone; see the disputed line above.

Where

  • Markham · City only

Who

  • JPJennifer PanThe accused on this case
  • DWDaniel Chi-Kwong WongCo-accused
  • LCLenford CrawfordCo-accused
  • DMDavid MylvaganamCo-accused
  • ECEric CartyCo-accused whose case was severed during the 2014 trial